No ESCAS breach: DAFF

08 Feb, 2013 08:32 AM

THE Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF) has found no evidence to support an allegation of cruelty to Australian cattle in an Indonesia abattoir, stemming from a complaint made by Animals Australia in October last year.

The investigation was also let down by the somewhat embarrassing failure of a key witness to give evidence, backing their original assertions.

Late yesterday, the Department released the findings of its investigation into the alleged incident, which suggested Australian cattle were slaughtered using traditional roping methods at an abattoir in West Java on September 27 to 28 last year.

The traditional slaughtering method doesn’t meet animal welfare guidelines, or the OIE standards, set out under the government’s new Exporter Supply Chain Assurance Scheme (ESCAS).

The Department said its investigation sought and obtained information from a range of sources including industry and Animals Australia, concluding there was “no evidence to support the allegation”.

“There is therefore no reason for DAFF to take any regulatory action in this case,” the statement said.

“No photographic evidence was provided by the complainant and the original informant was not prepared to be questioned.”

The Australian Livestock Exporters' Council declined to comment on the outcome, with CEO Alison Penfold saying the investigation found there was no non-compliance.

Greens NSW Senator and animal welfare spokesperson Lee Rhiannon raised the incident during a hearing of the Senate’s Rural and Regional Affairs Committee last November.

Senator Rhiannon alleged the animal cruelty was witnessed by Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) staff at the Chittagong abattoir on September 28 - but they failed to report the ESCAS breach.

MLA Trade and Economic Services General Manager Dr Peter Barnard said MLA staff and consultants had visited the Cibinong abattoir to conduct analysis - but was unsure of the exact date.

Senator Rhiannon was unhappy the breach was not reported to the Department and it was left to Animals Australia to make the actual complaint.

However, Dr Barnard said MLA’s role was “not as a policeman or regulator”.

“Our role is to assist supply chains with ESCAS compliance and we conduct that role diligently,” he said.

He was also forced to defend ESCAS, saying it had been embraced by industry to a “remarkable extent” and led to “remarkable results”.

“The fact that in Indonesia you have over 80 percent of animals there now stunned is a remarkable change in that country in the period of - just over a year,” he said.

“So the feedback that we have been giving government is generally positive.”

In a later media statement, Senator Rhiannon said, “MLA appeared to wash its hands of reporting supply chain breaches”.

In Senate question time later that month, the Senator urged Federal Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig to impose an obligation on MLA to report incidents of animal cruelty and any suspected ESCAS breaches they observed or became aware of.

Animals Australia and the Cattle Council of Australia were contacted for comment on the investigation result but did not respond before deadline.

Meanwhile, the Department is also conducting a range of investigations into alleged ESCAS breaches - some serious and some minor - but says it is unable to comment further until those investigations are complete.

The current investigations include issues with consignments to Pakistan, Kuwait, Mauritius, Israel, Indonesia and Qatar.

The Department was also reluctant to comment on reasons behind delays in implementing ESCAS in the Saudi Arabian market.

The delay is one of the reasons behind projections live sheep export numbers will fall to about 2 million head in 2013; the lowest level in 20 years.

Colin Bettles

Colin Bettles

is the national political writer for Fairfax Agricultural Media
Date: Newest first | Oldest first


John Niven
8/02/2013 9:05:58 AM

Seems Animals Australia are quite happy to accept cruelty to foreign animals.
8/02/2013 11:16:32 AM

Tell me why does anyone listen to this Animals Australia? Aren't they just a bunch a vegans who want any slaughting, humane or not, shut down? They shouldn't even be on anyone's radar for comment!
Real Deal
8/02/2013 11:18:24 AM

What would happen if the department of transport demonstrated the same diligence in finding people accused of exceeding the speed limit to be innocent?
8/02/2013 2:29:02 PM

Rhiannon needs to get over herself being unhappy and find something positive to do - i.e go save some whales - that should lift the morale a bit.
9/02/2013 10:45:37 PM

Vegan comes from ancient tribal slang that means, The village idoit who can't hunt,fish or ride and had all the intelliagence and ability to catch a lettuce.
Expose Animals Australia
10/02/2013 10:43:29 AM

Getting caught out in more lies Animals Australia. The only BAN is to BAN ANIMALS AUSTRALIA.
10/02/2013 3:57:55 PM

Actually, most Australians including many farmers, do not support the cruelty we've seen suffered by cattle, and actually support Animals Australia. Or are you saying that Australians actually think such cruelty is ok? A great many Australians support Animals Australia and Rhiannon's insistence on accountability. Do you insist on accountability?
11/02/2013 10:50:54 AM

HB. I do not know a single farmer that supports Animals Australia. As a Farmer, I support Animal Welfare. Australias presence in the Live Export Industry is the only solution to supporting Animal Welfare. Yet Animals Australia want it shut down. Where does this leave the animals who without Australias world leading Animals welfare standards will suffer ongoing cruetly. Why would farmers support something that offers no solution. AA want all slaughter shutdown. Humane or not. They arent interested in solutions. In fact they banned me from their facebook page for making this point!


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *


light grey arrow
Pleased that common sense has prevailed. Being close to the policy makers cannot be underestimated
light grey arrow
JohnCarpenter, The lamb and mutton job is going okay- we must be doing some things right.
light grey arrow
Spot on X. Let the Chinese buy as long as we can buy freely in China